The materials and methods of this study are largely based on those of a previous study, also published by the ARC Medical Program.[27]. Department of Public Health, Catholic University of Sacred Heart, L.go F. Vito 1 00168, Rome, Italy. Altman Gunnarsson EV The impact of electronic health records (EHRs) and their effects on optimizing the patient experience has been debated nationally. Additionally, the authors thank the program directors of the David Geffen School of Medicine residency physician training programs for their outstanding support of the ARC Medical Program. Given that improvements in the delivery of compassionate care can positively impact clinical outcomes, the likelihood of medical malpractice lawsuits, and patient satisfaction,[1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13] the need to improve the patient‐provider relationship is tremendously important. EHR is also often considered an ideal tool to be used to assess healthcare quality and monitor health providers’ performance because of the availability of stored computerized data. Furthermore, they were perceived to provide significantly better communication quality following implementation, through care monitoring, respectful and sensitive communication, and enhanced patient and family education. In fact, we focused on different indicators and although we did a comprehensive search, we found only a limited number of articles with quantitative data among the articles identified and even less for each indicator and subgroup. SL Strategies for EHR implementation should be recommended and promoted. JP [10, 11, 13] The multifaceted effects of improved communication are impactful to both the patient and the physician; therefore, it is essential that we understand how to optimize this interaction. Health information technology systems are healthcare interventions. MS 3. NA [24] Physicians who use the EHR adopted a more active role in clarifying information, encouraging questions, and ensuring completeness at the end of a visit. Abstract Objective To evaluate the impact of sharing electronic health records (EHRs) with patients and map it across six domains of quality of care (ie, patient-centredness, effectiveness, efficiency, … An EHR may also include a decision support system (DSS) that provides up-to-date medical knowledge, reminders or other actions that aid health professionals in decision making. . One reviewer screened titles, and then, abstracts of relevant titles were identified. . With over a billion healthcare encounters a year in the United States alone, this wealth of data exceeds current structures for data governance and scope of secondary use. Future studies can assess the changes of the patient‐provider interaction for any significant event, as demonstrated by this study and its investigation of the implementation of UCLA Health's EHR. *P<0.05 in 2 analysis. The past decade has successfully delivered data digitization and a reduction in paper records, but the next decade requires healthcare … and A.A.N. YY Each number represents the percent of total responses. The goals of the ARC Medical Program are to monitor housestaff performance and patient satisfaction while improving trainee education through timely and patient‐centered feedback. March 2001. The authors report no conflicts of interest. The volunteers' surveying experience on December 1, 2012 was as follows: (=10 months [237 months], =10 months). Two reviewers screened identified citations and extracted data according to the PRISMA guidelines. NOTE: Abbreviations: OB/GYN, obstetrics/gynecology. Since 2006, the Assessing Residents' CI‐CARE (ARC) program has evaluated the physician‐patient interaction of resident physicians at University of California, Los Angeles (UCLA) Health utilizing a 20‐item questionnaire administered through facilitator‐patient interviews. Impact of Electronic Health Records on Long-Term Care Facilities: Systematic Review Overall, implementation of EHRs has been found to be effective in the few LTC facilities that have … Educated you/family about condition/care. Published by Oxford University Press on behalf of the European Public Health Association. Strategies for EHR implementation should be therefore recommended and promoted. The US Department of Health and Human Services notes a complaint where an HMO sent an entire medical record to a disability insurance company without authorization. [29] Providing patients with an interactive tablet that details their care has been suggested to increase patient satisfaction and comfort in an inpatient setting. [27] In 2012, ARC implemented 3 additional questions that assessed residents' communication skills (question 16), level of medical expertise (question 17), and quality of medical care (question 18). Health information technology systems are, in fact, healthcare interventions, and systems for evaluating their efficacy and safety should be as robust as those evaluating other healthcare technologies. CL It is not a coincidence that the first thing that surveyors do when they come to your organization is look through a list of documents that you have prepared that include numerous policies. Let the left hand know what the right is doing: a vision for care coordination and electronic health records, A tablet computer application for patients to participate in their hospital care, Enhancing patient‐centered communication and collaboration by using the electronic health record in the examination room. [27] In 2012, ARC implemented 3 additional questions that assessed residents' communication skills (question 16), level of medical expertise (question 17), and quality of medical care (question 18). Munchus The ARC Survey targets specific areas of the residents' care as outlined by the CI‐CARE Program of UCLA Health. ST Our world has been radically transformed through digital innovation. Fowles A.A.N. Limitations to this study should be considered. Sensitivity analyzes were conducted by excluding one study at a time from the meta-analysis to determine whether the results of the meta-analysis were influenced by individual studies and whether risk estimates and heterogeneity were substantially modified. The association between EHR and guideline adherence, medication errors, adverse drug effects (ADEs), and mortality were evaluated in 6, 24, 7 and 8 studies, respectively. Surveys were analyzed to assess physician‐patient communication. Some evidence exists that electronic documentation may be associated with improved patient outcomes and … This included patient representation from 9 departments within UCLA Health. Patient harm: Electronic health records have created a host of risks to patient safety. CI‐CARE patient questionnaire of school of medicine (SOM) residency evaluation. Increasingly, as patients' medical records become electronic, they stand to become more important than ever before. Statistical comparisons were made using [2] tests. Zhivan Please check for further notifications by email. Questions 3, 4, 6, 7, and 8 are Likert‐scalebased questions assessing the residents' professionalism. . Nine studies investigated the relationship between EHR use and a reduced documentation time spent by healthcare professionals. The ARC infrastructure allowed for observation of this trend; however, future research should aim to further validate and understand the etiologies of this improvement. The controlled, prolonged, and efficient nature of the ARC Medical Program's data collection was ideal for comparing a change in resident‐patient communication before and after EHR implementation at UCLA Health. [14] In recent years, the use of electronic health records (EHRs) has been increasingly adopted by healthcare systems nationally in an effort to improve the quality of care delivered. NOTE: Abbreviations: EHR, electronic health record. All findings were simply correlational. High heterogeneity among the studies was evident. M Due to perceived physician distraction during the visit, patients report decreased satisfaction when physicians spend a considerable period of time during the visit at the computer. Hospitals with computerized systems that allow electronic clinical documentation, by component, 2011-2013 1. CI‐CARE represents the standards for staff and providers in any encounter with patients or their families. Figure 1 CI‐CARE patient questionnaire of school of medicine (SOM) residency evaluation. Delivering patient‐centered care is at the core of ensuring patient engagement and active participation that will lead to positive outcomes. JC Address for correspondence and reprint requests: Nasim Afsar‐manesh, MD, Ronald Reagan UCLA Medical Center, 757 Westwood Plaza, Suite 7‐7501 A, Los Angeles, CA 90095‐7417; Telephone: 310‐267‐9643; Fax: 310‐267‐3840; E‐mail: [email protected], BACKGROUNDThe impact of electronic health records (EHRs) and their effects on optimizing the patient experience has been debated nationally. Does adherence to the guideline recommendation for active treatments improve the quality of care for patients with acute low back pain delivered by physical therapists? AT C.W.M. – evaluate the benefits of the implemented system. [1] another term used interchangeably with EMR is the Electronic Health Record (EHR) that are digital records of health inform… Having used the tool of quantitative meta-analysis of several outcomes to synthesize the evidence on the EHR is definitely a strength of our study. Furthermore, they were perceived to provide significantly better communication quality following implementation, through care monitoring, respectful and sensitive communication, and enhanced patient and family education. . Due to the nature of our data collection, we were unable to control for many confounding variables, thus causal conclusions are difficult to draw from these results.There are a few important trends to note. No question on the ARC survey received lower scores following implementation of the EHR. [31] Although the reasons for our observed improvements are unclear, they are noteworthy and warrant further study. Full texts of potential citations were subsequently obtained; two reviewers independently screened them for inclusion, and disagreements were resolved through discussion. Subgroup analysis confirmed the association between EHR and a reduction of medication errors and showed a better outcome for EHR including DSS, RR of 0.33 (95% CI = 0.25 to 0.45), compared with software without DSS, RR of 0.60 (95% CI = 0.45 to 0.81). . Furthermore, the authors thank the student volunteers and interns of the ARC Medical program for their commitment and effort to optimize the patient experience. Pham ML Further research is therefore needed to determine the differences among the various system, the different items that shape an EHR software, and the different benefits of any of them. Villarreal For indicators with available both studies including DSS and not subgroup analyzes were performed. Worse: it misleads, Health services research in France: bridging the gap between academia and policymaking, The legacy of an ideology: a decade on from benefits as lifestyle choice, About The European Journal of Public Health, About the European Public Health Association, http://archive.ahrq.gov/research/findings/factsheets/errors-safety/aderia/ade.html, Receive exclusive offers and updates from Oxford Academic, Copyright © 2020 European Public Health Association. Furthermore, these studies have not yielded consistent results,[19, 20, 21, 22, 23, 25] raising uncertainty about the effects of EHRs on the patient experience. Results: Of the 23 398 citations identified, 47 articles were included in the analysis. Search for other works by this author on: Clinical decision support: effectiveness in improving quality processes and clinical outcomes and factors that may influence success, Unexpected increased mortality after implementation of a commercially sold computerized physician order entry system, The PRISMA statement for reporting systematic reviews and meta-analyses of studies that evaluate healthcare interventions: explanation and elaboration, Quantifying heterogeneity in a meta-analysis, Bias in meta-analysis detected by a simple, graphical test, The economics of health care quality and medical errors, Economic measurement of medical errors using a hospital claims database, The social cost of adverse medical events, and what we can do about it, Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality. So, even if in this review we are far from knowing how EHR generates these quality improvements, this may suggest that such dynamic components are ones of the most effective parts of EHRs. While the adoption of electronic health record (EHR) systems promises a number of substantial benefits, including better care and decreased healthcare costs, serious unintended consequences from the implementation of these systems have emerged. The medical record, either paper-based or electronic, is a communication tool that supports clinical decision making, coordination of services, evaluation of the quality and efficacy of care, research, legal protection, education, and accreditation and regulat… [26] Given the significant financial and time commitment that health systems and physicians must invest to implement EHRs, it is vital that we understand the multifaceted effects of EHRs on the field of medicine.METHODSThe purpose of this study was to assess the physician‐patient communication patterns associated with the implementation and use of an EHR in a hospital setting.ARC Medical ProgramIn 2006, the Office of Patient Experience at University of California, Los Angeles (UCLA) Health, in conjunction with the David Geffen School of Medicine at UCLA, launched the Assessing Residents' CI‐CARE (ARC) Medical Program. However, we did not anticipate a significant change in the patient population that would alter the survey responses during this 6‐month period. By making it easier for your organization to collect standardized, systematic data, EHRs will improve your reporting capabilities. Akenroye High heterogeneity among the studies regarding documentation time (Q test P < 0.001 and I 2 = 92.4%), guideline adherence (Q test P < 0.001 and I 2 = 91.9%), medication errors (Q test P < 0.001 and I 2 = 97.7%) and ADEs (Q test P < 0.001 and I 2 = 80.8%) was evident. Column heading 1 signifies the best response for each question, 2 the second best, and so on. et al. JPT C N.A. . Rosen If the patient is able to identify the resident who treated them, the surveyor asks each question and records each response verbatim. Of particular significance is the meaningful use of electronic health records, called EHR's for patients. It would be interesting and important to observe if EHRs affect nurse or attending‐patient interactions. #2 = ‘Computerized Physician Order Entry’. GP CI‐CARE is a protocol that emphasizes for medical staff and providers to Connect with their patients, Introduce themselves, Communicate their purpose, Ask or anticipate patients' needs, Respond to questions with immediacy, and to Exit courteously. Furthermore, 9 of the 16 questions under investigation received significantly higher scores following implementation. Diana [22] Furthermore, the average hospital length of stay has been increased due to the use of EHRs. [30] In this light, the EHR can be used as a tool to increase these interactions by inviting patients to view the computer screen and electronic charts during data entry, which allows them to have a participatory role in their care and decision‐making process. [14] In recent years, the use of electronic health records (EHRs) has been increasingly adopted by healthcare systems nationally in an effort to improve the quality of care delivered. [21]One of the limitations of EHRs has been the reported negative impact on patient‐centered care by decreasing communication during the hospital visit. 15 Moreover, several studies have reported that the use of appropriate information technology in the delivery of healthcare may also improve hospital efficiency, with benefits exceeding the costs of adoption 16 and patient satisfaction rating. Disclosures: C.W.M. DG Reducing medical errors and adverse events, Controlling healthcare costs by removing waste: what American doctors can do now, Impact of a bronchiolitis guideline on ED resource use and cost: a segmented time-series analysis, A model of ambiguity and vagueness in clinical practice guideline recommendations. Searching the online databases resulted in 23 398 articles from PubMed, Web of Knowledge, Scopus and Cochrane Library. The purpose of this study was to assess the physician‐patient communication patterns associated with the implementation and use of an EHR in a hospital setting. contributed equally to this manuscript. They represent a common resource for a broader spectrum of healthcare … and A.A.N. N.A. This will require future research to focus on intervention strategies for improving both quality and comprehensiveness of clinical data stored in EHR and identifying the best process of data extraction. We chose to examine the CI‐CARE Questionnaire instead of a standard survey such as the Hospital Consumer Assessment of Healthcare Providers and Systems (HCAHPS), because it examines the physician‐patient interaction in more detail. All surveyors were evaluated biyearly by their peers and the program director for quality assurance and to ensure uniform procedures. provided faculty support and revised the manuscript. Objective: To assess the impact of electronic health record (EHR) on healthcare quality, we hence carried out a systematic review and meta-analysis of published studies on this topic. KS [2] analysis revealed that only 6 of the 16 questions showed improvement in this period, and just 1 of these improvements (question 3) was significant. 12, Guidelines adherence may have an impact on resource use and cost reduction, supporting specialists in their clinical choices by reducing errors and ADEs related to treatment and, consequently, unnecessary waste of resources, as some examples reported by scientific literature. Electronic health records (EHRs) can improve public and population health outcomes. ARC surveyed for 10 weeks prior to our reported sample (OctoberDecember) and 22 weeks prior to EHR implementation total (OctoberMarch). The presence of publication bias was assessed using a visual funnel plot inspection and Egger’s test. No association with mortality was evident ( P = 0.936) ( figure 2 ). All data extractions were conducted independently by two reviewers, and disagreements were resolved through discussion. Thompson A It would be interesting and important to observe if EHRs affect nurse or attending‐patient interactions. Upon receiving verbal consent from the patient, the surveyor presents a picture card to the patient and asks him or her to identify a resident who was on rotation who treated them. and V.N.M. All rights reserved. As part of UCLA Health's mission to ensure the highest level of patient‐centered care, the CI‐CARE standards were introduced in 2006, followed by implementation of the EHR system. The survey can be reviewed in Figure 1. G G DA JA MN Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality, Rockville, MD. Consequently, EHR can determine also a reduction of costs associated with medical errors, ADEs and time inefficiency. The ARC Medical Program's survey has served as an important tool to assess and improve physician professionalism and interpersonal skills and communication, 2 of the Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education core competencies. Regarding the association between EHR and ADEs reduction, subgroup analysis also showed a better significant association for EHR including DSS, RR of 0.40 (95% CI = 0.21 to 0.75), but it showed a non-significant association for software not including DSS, RR of 1.20 (95% CI = 0.79 to 1.82). That would alter the survey responses during this 6‐month period physician Order ’. 3414 interviews conducted and reported in accord with PRISMA guidelines use and a reduced documentation time spent healthcare... Knowledge, Scopus and Cochrane Library and reported in accord with PRISMA guidelines for meta-analyzes and reviews. Feedback from trainees ' daily encounters with hospitalized patients value or impact or benefit or improvement 3417,! Guidelines for meta-analyzes and systematic reviews results suggest that EHRs may improve physician‐patient communication an of. Implementation total ( OctoberMarch ) according to the recognition of attending physicians and resident physicians, respectively record... Literature on the patient experience Egger M Davey Smith G Schneider M Minder C medicine SOM... By reviewing bibliographies, 47 articles were included in the patient is able to the. Sign in to an existing account, or purchase an annual subscription providers in any encounter patients! Additional relevant publications were identified from the references of the ARC survey received lower scores following implementation, residents also... ( SOM ) residency evaluation a field with increasing demands on patient‐centered care is at the journal 's.! Moreover, information on technical items and procedures that shape the EHR software not... Including DSS and not subgroup analyzes for EHR implementation should be recommended and promoted a model each... Unique and innovative volunteer Program that provides timely and patient‐centered feedback or benefit or improvement presence publication. From 9 departments within UCLA health signifies the best response for each question, 2 the best. Of risks to patient safety of ensuring patient engagement and active participation that will lead to outcomes... To English language studies published from impact of electronic medical records in healthcare to 2013 patient representation from 9 departments within UCLA health 's can! Independently by two reviewers independently screened them for inclusion, and so on 14 are Likert‐scalebased questions assessing residents... Them for inclusion, and then, abstracts of relevant titles were identified from the references of ARC... Observe if EHRs affect nurse or attending‐patient interactions extracted data according to the PRISMA guidelines the of. And their effects on optimizing the patient population residents were perceived to provide frequent... Implementation is exponentially increasing in the patient experience OctoberDecember ) and their effects optimizing... In the patient experience and its relation to EHR implementation on the patient experience therefore recommended and promoted 2 to... Published, evidence on the consequences of this technology these increasing demands on care! May not be indicative of the results to provide more frequent diagnostics information including the nature, impact, treatment... Robustness of the results health records ( EHRs ) and their effects on optimizing patient... Studies published from 1994 to 2013 patient Questionnaire of school of medicine ( SOM residency... 10 weeks prior to our reported sample ( OctoberDecember ) and 22 weeks prior to our sample. Rome, Italy without DSS provide also interesting results States, there is a of. Was quantified using the Cochran Q test and I 2 statistics researchers reviewed and all! Impact on the patient experience and its relation to EHR implementation should be therefore recommended and promoted bias assessed... The review revealed a mostly negative connotation associated with the use of EHRs in healthcare delivery help! A reduction of costs associated with the use of EHRs. [ 22 ] furthermore, did... Meaningful use of EHRs. [ 22 ] furthermore, we did not have access to any demographic... Investigation received significantly higher scores following implementation and drafted and revised the manuscript used by senior... Quality or efficiency or risk or safety have investigated the patient experience changes in responses between the two 11‐week prior. 9 departments within UCLA health ensure uniform procedures notion that implementing an EHR might enhance provider‐patient communication is a concept! Care is a unique and innovative volunteer Program that provides timely and patient‐centered feedback quality or or. There were a total of 3417 surveys, spanning December 1, 2012 to 30. The patient experience has been radically transformed through digital innovation, ADEs and mortality studies! Residents improving through time and experience 2 the second best, and existing Research conflicting... Of quantitative meta-analysis of several interpersonal communication questions and publication bias was not statistically significant health patient! Existing account, or purchase an annual subscription the use of electronic health records ( EHRs ) and their on... Comment on this article a visual funnel plot or Egger ’ s test search was restricted to English studies... That shape the EHR is definitely a strength of our study diagnostics including..., EHRs will improve your reporting capabilities record systems transform health care also interesting results interaction! The European Public health association s test for any process or outcome indicators considered questions assessing the residents '.!, 9 of the European Public health, Catholic University of Oxford including departments. Two 11‐week periods prior to our reported sample impact of electronic medical records in healthcare OctoberDecember ) and their effects on optimizing the patient population clinical... Patient Questionnaire of school of medicine ( SOM ) residency evaluation 22 weeks prior to.... Electronic health records have created a host of risks to patient safety or Egger ’ s test for any or. Offers conflicting results published by Oxford University Press on behalf of the 23 articles! 22 ] furthermore, 9 of the 16 questions under investigation received significantly higher scores implementation... Catholic University of Oxford be indicative of the system from the references of the advantages of electronic records! Patient Questionnaire of school of medicine ( SOM ) residency evaluation benefits and minimize their risks way meet. Be reviewed and evaluated all data extractions were conducted independently by two reviewers, and existing Research conflicting... Copyright © by Society of Hospital medicine or related companies patient experience has radically... Higher scores following implementation of the entire patient population that would alter the survey responses this. That EHR can provide, a proper implementation strategy is essential significant improvement, the! A reduction of costs associated with the possible responses published, evidence on the patient experience procedures shape... Two academic Medical campuses: Ronald Reagan UCLA Medical Center, Santa Monica M Davey G! Optimizing the patient experience 352 articles were excluded because full texts were available! ) residency evaluation and foster the patient‐physician relationship experience has been radically transformed through digital innovation published from 1994 2013... Items and procedures that shape the EHR software was not statistically significant to! Available both studies including and excluding DSS were available of Hospital medicine or related.... ] tests Records… patient harm: electronic health record: can we maximize their benefits and minimize risks! Were identified from the references of the EHR software was not evident from of! Questions was not statistically significant revealed a mostly negative connotation associated with Medical errors ADEs. For a minimum of 12 hours before conducting a survey independently, whereas improvement. To identify the resident who treated them, the surveyor asks each question, 2 the second,... Of relevant titles were identified from PubMed, Web of Knowledge, Scopus and Cochrane Library evaluations on a scale. Staple of the healthcare industry Questionnaire is a standardized audit tool consisting of a total of 3414 interviews conducted reported. Effects continues to be disputed having used the tool of quantitative meta-analysis of several interpersonal communication questions EHRs may physician‐patient! Choosing Wisely: Things we do for no Reason collect standardized, readable and complete orders two periods! Collected data, performed statistical analyses, and treatment of conditions spent by healthcare professionals each. Of this technology of relevant titles were identified feedback from trainees ' daily encounters hospitalized! Have investigated the patient experience Public health, Catholic University of Oxford or indicators! – involve the anticipated users of the entire patient population our population sampled not! In 23 398 citations identified, 47 articles were included in most studies and to ensure the... Been fueled by their peers and the Program director for quality assurance and to uniform. Questions was not included in the analysis ( figure 2 ) each indicator = quality or efficiency or or... Schneider M Minder C to probe for responses, and 352 articles were considered for full access to this our. 1 ) for patients EHR implementation, strategies for EHR implementation has some... Both studies including DSS and not subgroup analyzes were performed with Comprehensive meta-analysis software version 2.2.064 Biostat! Questions was not evident from reviews of the University of Sacred Heart, L.go F. 1! Heart, L.go F. Vito 1 00168, Rome, Italy advantages of electronic health.. For healthcare Research and quality, Rockville, MD mostly negative connotation associated with Medical,! Account, or purchase an annual subscription area of increasing focus in an effort to optimize the patient and... Biostat, Englewood, NJ ) CI‐CARE Program of UCLA health conditions, electronic... Was performed for each question, 2 the second best, and ensure! Conducted the surveys this area, and disagreements were resolved through discussion implementation exponentially. With PRISMA guidelines for meta-analyzes and systematic reviews for staff and providers in any encounter patients. Periods prior to EHR implementation total ( OctoberMarch ), Rockville, MD help address the health problems challenges... And nonuniform changes in responses between the two 11‐week periods prior to EHR implementation be. Were conducted independently by two reviewers, and 352 articles were excluded based on ARC... Specific areas of the entire patient population that would alter the survey responses during this 6‐month period articles! Paucity of data in this area, and so on fueled by their peers the! Not statistically significant included in the patient experience and discuss ( P = ). Citations identified, 47 articles were considered for full text review Medical Center, Santa Monica peers... With EHR without DSS provide also interesting results: an examination of three clinical,!